More Reviews IN THE
MIX
USA TODAY
By
Elysa Gardner, USA TODAY
Published: February 13, 2013
Jamaica Kincaid’s ‘See Now Then’ is one quirky read
"Like Kincaid's ex-husband, Allen Shawn, Mr. Sweet is a composer. They
live in a small New England town, as Shawn and Kincaid did, and have a
son and daughter, as the former couple do. But Kincaid's first book in
nearly a decade is not a barely fictionalized memoir, or so the author
has insisted. As she recently told a reporter, her real children are
not, like the Sweet kids, named Heracles and Persephone, and 'my
daughter doesn't disappear underground every six months and emerge in
the spring.'
Such coyness is pervasive in
See Now Then —
though so is bawdy humor and unabashed rage and sorrow. There are
passages that are almost unbearably self-pitying, with Kincaid — um,
that is, Mrs. Sweet — lamenting her husband's disdain for her Caribbean
heritage and no-longer-youthful figure. We learn, too, of the 'turbulence and upheaval' she has endured from childhood on: 'I seemed
unable to do anything that pleased anyone and that included me,' she
writes toward the end."
LOS ANGELES TIMES
By Hector Tobar, Los Angeles Times
Published: February 1, 2013
Jamaica Kincaid scrolls through time in 'See Now Then'
"As fictional characters, the Sweets live in the protective bubble of
art: We are moved by their experiences but don't feel the cringe that
comes from seeing real people hurt themselves. But there are enough
parallels to the real Kincaid's life — Mrs. Sweet gardens, and Kincaid
has written and edited several books on the topic — that reading "See
Now Then" can feel uncomfortably voyeuristic."
THE NEW YORK TIMES
Published: February 12, 2013
The Marriage Has Ended; Revenge Begins
"When Dorothy Parker drank too much, Gore Vidal once reported, she
sometimes suffered from what she ruefully called “the frankies”: the
inclination to tell people, as if for their own good, what she really
thought of them.
There’s something about the men of the Shawn family — William, the longtime editor of The New Yorker,
who died in 1992, and now his son, Allen, a composer — that seems to give women the frankies while sober.
In 1998 Lillian Ross published
“Here but Not Here,”
a memoir of her 40-year affair with the married William Shawn. She
outed this famously private man, while his wife was still living, as an
enthusiast for pornography who “longed for the earthiest and wildest
kinds of sexual adventures,” among many other things."
Polly Rosenwaike
Friday, February 8, 2013
'See Now Then,' by Jamaica Kincaid
"If we're tempted to see the tall, Caribbean-born, garden-loving,
synagogue-going Mrs. Sweet - scribbling away at her desk in Vermont - as
a stand-in (a sugar substitute?) for the author, Kincaid seems to be
egging us on.
One can't help thinking that Kincaid's easily Googleable ex-husband will
not be pleased by the arrival of "See Now Then." How should the rest of
us feel? Exhilarated, grateful - and relieved, perhaps, that Kincaid
can't see inside our own heads."